Two maritime professionals comparing a paper inspection report with laptop records in a shipboard office

A seller says the ship’s port State control (PSC) deficiencies were dealt with. Your database search still shows the original findings, and a later inspection lists a similar category. Before treating that as an unresolved defect or a recurring failure, connect each entry to the inspection report and its required action. A repair invoice, a database entry and a release from detention answer different questions.

This guide helps buyers review PSC history before purchasing a used ship. The ship acquisition due-diligence guide covers the wider purchase review. Here the output is a comparison of regional database entries, original inspection reports and the seller’s supporting records, identifying what remains to be clarified.

1. Define what your PSC history search actually covers

Match the candidate vessel by its IMO number and reconcile any different names in the documents. Keep those identifiers in the transaction file. Record the database searched, retrieval date, inspection date range and search filters. A name-only search or an unexplained screenshot makes it difficult for another adviser to reproduce the result.

Choose sources relevant to the vessel’s trading history. The Tokyo MOU PSC database page describes its coverage as inspections by member Authorities and explains that displayed information reflects the inspection-time situation. One regional search is therefore a defined evidence source, rather than a complete worldwide history or a statement of today’s condition.

For each returned inspection, request the original report and available attachments from the seller. Keep public-search results separate from documents supplied by the vessel. If a report is absent, record the missing inspection reference and the question it prevents you answering. An empty search result does not establish an inspection-free history.

2. Compare report fields before interpreting the outcome

The Paris MoU inspection-outcome guidance describes Form A and, where deficiencies are found, Form B. It distinguishes the deficiency code identifying the issue from the action required. Review the description, applicable reference and rectification timeframe together. A total deficiency count omits these distinctions.

Compare Question for the buyer’s review
Inspection identity Do the vessel identifier, date, inspecting Authority and report reference connect this document to the database entry?
Deficiency detail What component, location and observed condition does the original wording identify? Is the public description abbreviated?
Required action Which action code, timeframe and instructions apply under that inspection’s regime?
Supporting record Does the seller’s evidence address this exact finding, and what does any subsequent Authority document establish?

Under the Paris MoU explanation, action code 10 records correction verified by the PSC officer during the inspection. Code 17 calls for correction before departure; where the ship is not detained, officer verification is not normally required. These are different evidence positions. Read any specific instructions and avoid applying the example across every regional regime.

Also distinguish release from detention from other outstanding matters. A release document should be read for its actual scope. It is not a blanket assurance covering every maintenance issue or the vessel’s condition at the buyer’s later inspection. Keep the pre-purchase condition survey as a separate assessment.

3. Worked comparison: three records, three buyer questions

Fictional document example: a buyer receives three historical inspection records for a trading ship. All events are invented, with no real ship, port, owner or incident represented. Assume the original reports use the Paris MoU action meanings described above. The event labels below are internal case references, not official deficiency codes.

Record comparison Conclusion and remaining question
P-01: The public record lists a fire-door finding. The original report identifies Door A and shows action 10. Retain the historical finding with its verified correction at that inspection. Do not relabel it unresolved solely because it still appears in history. Its condition today remains a separate survey question.
P-02: A later entry has the same deficiency category. Its report identifies Door B; the seller describes both entries as the same repaired item. The location descriptions conflict with that explanation. Ask the seller to reconcile the item identities. Two entries in one category justify investigation, but do not alone prove recurrence of Door A’s defect or establish a common cause.
P-03: Another report specifies action 17, with no detention. The seller supplies a dated work entry for the named item before departure; there is no subsequent PSC revisit record in the supplied file. Check the work entry’s identity, timing and supporting evidence against the original instructions. Under the stated action meaning, absence of a revisit is not sufficient to call the item unrectified. The seller’s record also does not establish an Authority-verified closure that it does not document.

The buyer’s resulting queries are specific: obtain the complete P-01 report if only an extract was supplied; resolve the Door A/Door B discrepancy in P-02; and assess the evidence against P-03’s requirements. None of these decisions can be made reliably by adding the three database entries together or accepting the seller’s general “all cleared” statement.

4. Resolve record gaps without rewriting inspection history

The Tokyo MOU FAQ distinguishes database closure from a company’s repair evidence: closure requires PSC verification through follow-up inspection, normally physical, with remote verification possible where physical attendance is impractical. It also says a requested follow-up is neither mandatory for the company nor an obligation for the Authority. Read this within the Tokyo MOU context, alongside the actual inspection requirements.

When the seller’s account and a public record differ, retain both and state the precise discrepancy. Ask for the complete inspection report, missing instructions or relevant subsequent correspondence. Where an official record needs clarification or correction, the Tokyo MOU directs queries to the inspecting port State Authority; the buyer’s spreadsheet cannot amend that record.

Finish with an inspection-by-inspection query list showing what is evidenced, what is missing and who should clarify it. Separate historical record questions from present-condition checks and contractual decisions. Avoid turning detention counts into an automatic discount or assuming a clean search guarantees a sound purchase.

When shortlisting bulk carriers for sale, request the available PSC report file early, with the vessel’s trading history. That gives the technical adviser time to identify documentary gaps before the purchase review reaches its decision point.

Golden Shipyard — sale & purchase

Buying, or want a second opinion?

Our sale & purchase desk can help you find, value and inspect the right tonnage. Tell us what you’re looking for and we’ll revert within one working day.